Year % of total safety net benefits 2008 34.050662990731 2009 32.2786893579737 2010 32.4266214392837 2011 31.834114060356 2012 31.1290091960905 2013 31.2800399121723 2014 32.3460579997989 2015 33.2009017756951 2016 31.6147200726078 2017 37.4800438915189 2018 35.9321443708874 2019 29.7816777198833