Year % of expense 2006 20.890171388597413 2007 24.451277750599857 2008 15.324301766348306 2009 20.463701794273963 2010 17.141807253307977 2011 15.945781435143077 2012 12.241107585111836 2013 12.5600823680975 2014 14.740228485369725 2015 17.350295260790944 2016 20.31463674387421 2017 20.360489288940865 2018 23.383182244600285 2019 24.934205793978805 2020 27.96426529504791 2021 27.76073783038055 2022 21.701093541526202