Year % of total safety net benefits 2008 29.5426068005401 2009 27.6286364395846 2010 29.20369601357 2012 28.5771032446639 2013 23.7958468467533 2014 26.3943493741623 2015 24.5267875273344 2016 27.1415666156833 2017 24.7596930638746 2018 24.0205946131343 2019 28.1325830507726