Year % of general government expenditure 1988 8.944315545243619 1989 11.3384321223709 1990 10.9118673647469 1991 9.33333333333333 1992 7.82842582106455 1993 7.010658914728681 1994 6.98630136986301 1995 7.915873015873021 1996 6.9722540045766594 1997 6.20600656968559 1998 5.64335535976505 1999 7.103377686796319 2000 8.76964433416046 2001 6.83322022395657 2002 6.12340362340362 2003 5.88235294117647 2004 5.57158560043968 2005 5.1344860710855 2006 4.55896406727829 2007 4.651914470412731 2008 2.64857578244051 2009 3.8934664598681703 2010 5.36644190871369 2011 3.6610470659616903 2012 3.56728964335265 2013 3.3034184984299197 2014 3.7586231936678502 2015 3.56627356993207 2016 3.62954572464199 2017 4.47818415142765 2018 3.83237010595501 2019 3.4148655772272005 2020 3.42880634030623 2021 2.81121610517666 2022 2.59622975013729