Year % of expense 2009 18.84187260999654 2010 23.14086101455864 2011 25.438093586144987 2012 27.048888409238074 2013 25.553089342069 2014 26.621075996991767 2015 33.12170707180498 2016 32.30072738259482 2017 30.64971766759537 2018 30.693665866646025 2019 32.839593863737996 2020 32.55227031173175 2021 32.247911498916146 2022 32.458978744306364