Year Percent 2005 4.6769 2006 2.9293 2007 3.4866 2008 2.6272 2009 3.0454 2010 4.0166 2011 4.5447 2012 3.5711 2013 4.1238 2014 6.0551 2015 4.6698 2016 3.7676 2017 4.1349