Year Percent 1989 48.2 1990 45.5 1991 40.8 1992 41.4 1993 42.8 1994 43.5 1995 43.8 1996 43.7 1997 41.4 1998 44.6 1999 41.9 2001 41.6 2002 42.7 2003 45.1 2004 44.9 2005 46.1 2006 44 2007 43.1 2008 43 2009 38.4 2010 40.2 2011 44.3 2012 44.1 2013 40.2 2014 38.1 2015 37 2016 36.8