Year % of general government expenditure 1988 9.159663865546221 1989 8.27896512935883 1990 8.741721854304629 1991 8.48837209302326 1992 9.32504440497336 1993 4.527665317139 1994 3.84025559105431 1995 4.29571984435798 1996 3.54533152909337 1997 3.6986442866365397 1998 2.8551724137931 1999 3.1718415417558896 2000 3.03030303030303 2001 3.79707088459285 2002 2.97798420808175 2003 3.885949441505 2004 4.7557003257329 2005 4.11167512690355 2006 3.2459271387638102 2007 3.50447966919366 2008 4.26123936816525 2009 3.17877969762419 2010 2.1343217197924402 2011 2.35425578350065 2012 2.4264049955397002 2013 2.7428949107733 2014 6.810717372515129 2015 4.0613414223121005 2016 4.07479765559587 2017 4.1158123135340405 2018 3.6345966958211897 2019 3.6974483596597802 2020 2.9684675046804 2021 6.31656973778186 2022 3.20289724671585