Year Percent 1993 4.6 1996 4.3 2004 3.6 2005 3.8 2006 3.7 2007 3.9 2008 3.9 2009 3.8 2010 3.7 2011 3.7 2012 3.9 2013 3.8 2014 3.9 2015 3.9