Year Percent 1998 4.2 1999 4.48 2002 5.74 2006 4.74 2007 4.44 2008 3.92 2009 5.09 2010 5.22 2011 8.32 2012 8.36 2013 9.14 2014 9.79 2015 8.71 2016 8.14 2017 7.85 2018 7.58 2019 6.09