Year Percent 1987 15.4 1989 14.2 1993 13.8 2004 13.5 2005 12.5 2006 13.8 2007 13.8 2008 13.9 2009 14.1 2010 13.4 2011 13.7 2012 13.3 2013 13 2014 13.2 2015 13.3