Year Percent 1987 3.84 1988 4.87 1989 3.7 1990 6.24 1991 4.92 1992 3.79 1993 4.23 1994 3.74 1995 4.96 1996 3.86 1997 4.1 1998 3.97 1999 4.22 2000 3.34 2001 3.55 2003 3.61 2004 3.53 2005 3.46 2006 3.2 2007 2.76 2008 2.62 2009 2.33 2010 2.86 2011 2.98 2012 3.31 2013 4.12 2014 3.7 2015 4.01 2016 3.63 2017 3.19