Year Percent 1990 9.41 1992 11.91 1993 11.84 1995 11.9 1996 10.23 1997 10.73 1998 10.14 1999 10.98 2000 5.5 2001 8.55 2002 8.51 2003 8.27 2004 8.09 2005 8.12 2006 7.17 2007 6.8 2008 5.88 2009 5.54 2011 4.14 2012 4.58 2013 4.59 2014 4.26 2015 4.18 2016 3.52 2017 3.61