Quarter Percent 2008-12-31 -0.8 2009-03-31 -3 2009-06-30 -3.8 2009-09-30 -4.5 2009-12-31 -4.6 2010-03-31 -4.3 2010-06-30 -5.2 2010-09-30 -5.3 2010-12-31 -4.5 2011-03-31 -3.6 2011-06-30 -2.9 2011-09-30 -2 2011-12-31 -3 2012-03-31 -3.7 2012-06-30 -4.3 2012-09-30 -4.5 2012-12-31 -3.3 2013-03-31 -1.1 2013-06-30 1.5 2013-09-30 4.1 2013-12-31 4.7 2014-03-31 6.2 2014-06-30 7.3 2014-09-30 8.2 2014-12-31 9.1 2015-03-31 10 2015-06-30 10 2015-09-30 10.2 2015-12-31 11.1 2016-03-31 11.2 2016-06-30 12 2016-09-30 12.1 2016-12-31 11.1 2017-03-31 10.5 2017-06-30 7.8 2017-09-30 5.3 2017-12-31 4.1 2018-03-31 1.6 2018-06-30 2.2 2018-09-30 2.4 2018-12-31 2.5 2019-03-31 3.2 2019-06-30 3.1 2019-09-30 3.5 2019-12-31 3.5 2020-03-31 3.3 2020-06-30 -1.2 2020-09-30 -4.4 2020-12-31 -6.5 2021-03-31 -8.9 2021-06-30 -5.3 2021-09-30 -2.7 2021-12-31 0.3 2022-03-31 3.5 2022-06-30 6.5 2022-09-30 8 2022-12-31 7.1 2023-03-31 6.9 2023-06-30 6 2023-09-30 5.4 2023-12-31 6.3