Year % of government expenditure 1989 12.9058904647827 1990 13.8518800735474 1991 16.3537693023682 1992 12.7515697479248 1993 12.7980003356934 1994 16.7000198364258 1995 15.12972021102905 1996 14.410475254058849 1997 13.716215133667 1998 8.92667007446289 1999 11.2300395965576 2000 14.263860225677501 2001 16.07828998565675 2002 16.324569702148448 2003 13.636205196380601 2004 11.7330198287964 2005 14.2693700790405 2007 17.1730499267578 2008 19.1193809509277 2009 17.5528392791748 2010 14.5029697418213 2011 15.35146522521975 2012 15.24162960052495 2013 16.15192985534665 2014 16.15324449539185 2015 16.179239749908447 2016 15.438560485839801 2017 14.3227701187134 2018 14.618000030517601 2019 13.8279948234558 2020 11.7162704467773 2021 13.7222099304199 2022 13.066929817199725 2023 7.92199993133545