Year Percent 2006 -35.1955 2007 -35.18115 2008 -38.58531 2009 -34.87622 2010 -35.56984 2011 -33.26127 2012 -29.10399 2013 -27.69488 2014 -28.71486 2015 -28.45236 2016 -27.62074 2017 -26.77047