Year Percent 1986 14.2 1991 11.1 1996 9.1 2002 12.8 2004 10.3 2005 11.81 2006 11.52 2007 10.77 2008 10.63 2009 12.11 2010 13.68 2011 12.49 2012 12.27 2013 10.6 2014 10.68 2015 11.17 2016 12.62 2017 12.23 2018 12.19 2019 10.74 2020 9.69