Year Percent 1989 18 1991 20.7 1995 12.5 1996 14.1 1998 20 1999 16.3 2000 12.2 2001 13.5 2002 14 2003 14.8 2004 10.9 2005 10.4 2006 6.9 2007 4.5 2008 6.7 2009 6.4 2010 5.5 2011 4.5 2012 4.1 2013 3.2 2014 3 2015 1.9 2016 2.2