Year Percent 1990 4.31 1992 5.46 1993 5.6 1995 5.09 1996 4.83 1997 4.65 1998 4.58 1999 4.81 2000 3.05 2001 3.99 2002 3.92 2003 3.93 2004 4.03 2005 3.68 2006 3.29 2007 3.24 2008 2.53 2009 2.43 2011 1.64 2012 1.85 2013 1.78 2014 1.63 2015 1.65 2016 1.39 2017 1.46