Year Percent 2009-01-01 4.1788200000000000 2010-01-01 3.1986000000000000 2011-01-01 3.2935800000000004 2012-01-01 3.2553000000000000 2013-01-01 3.0767000000000000 2014-01-01 2.5869500000000000 2015-01-01 2.4283000000000000 2016-01-01 2.4441000000000000