Year % of general government expenditure 1988 14.63976105733858 1989 13.461044955854916 1990 12.229516117358006 1991 10.803798830049832 1992 10.410655740000815 1993 13.382673052651384 1994 12.942306614635601 1995 13.270827652297113 1996 12.838390935162092 1997 12.798307301648581 1998 12.369797068747818 1999 13.04487131028623 2000 13.205392153518591 2001 12.237596478438961 2002 11.632487055286035 2003 11.391525665323742 2004 12.41408017530185 2005 12.198099980814169 2006 11.446137401177744 2007 10.247050089619744 2008 10.155911198677112 2009 11.206869951183805 2010 10.59025557456041 2011 10.35431281417206 2012 10.03502427042486 2013 10.063655640909104 2014 10.35410206826856 2015 9.993730616361102 2016 10.210654590173434 2017 10.268104136677465 2018 10.161926513464481 2019 9.974412734498866 2020 9.524745084855395 2021 9.01498803771639 2022 9.068682892967225