Year 1=extremely underdeveloped to 7=well developed and efficient by international standards 2007 3.98719692740559 2008 4.02291788593798 2009 4.14955426873636 2010 4.26919786894546 2011 4.27272727272727 2012 4.29090909090909 2013 4.34545454545455 2014 4.38181818181818 2015 4.23527874780233 2016 4.23636363636364 2017 4.23636363636364