Year % of general government expenditure 1988 6.1712605867100905 1989 5.990363949348912 1990 5.632900302468021 1991 5.228525965849428 1992 4.77952900915697 1993 4.463034412639638 1994 4.343892061317555 1995 3.993823451881876 1996 4.075573784280126 1997 4.1339062688129244 1998 4.165828367657893 1999 4.171205936513361 2000 4.329503619480371 2001 4.310752590536792 2002 4.303893649253499 2003 4.237764316426368 2004 4.231915203249634 2005 4.158578700397523 2006 4.232711169512329 2007 4.180017018268976 2008 4.119690065517357 2009 3.9688307935650253 2010 3.933234374734386 2011 3.954089354078548 2012 4.063872619313149 2013 4.029444405873407 2014 3.963268952675339 2015 3.928606240661243 2016 3.986146869208062 2017 3.9414736037572697 2018 3.9430447408128493 2019 4.082588583435448 2020 3.807732859814464 2021 3.7937988239676415 2022 4.151417359033652