Year % of general government expenditure 1996 4.3264686900694596 1997 4.08718011509734 1998 4.06423947351732 1999 4.1564292515269 2000 5.0192275134834405 2001 5.38700339807862 2002 4.8713974545291405 2003 3.66772504203208 2004 3.828258295028 2005 3.8328337595256 2006 3.7786954680220197 2007 3.8977194329950304 2008 3.8542036442212697 2009 4.1471874284817805 2010 3.85883473112529 2011 3.7573679694535995 2012 3.7033028402272397 2013 3.5503020819663402 2014 3.4536698010216202 2015 3.5484533660757696 2016 3.40062637293213 2017 3.6924902790698004 2018 3.89797763037368 2019 3.70032484816879 2020 3.15365367554262 2021 3.31972886380933 2022 2.8652553414738198