Year % of general government expenditure 1988 8.428295503165199 1989 8.8353546647689 1990 12.364506022539599 1991 11.1183095546909 1992 9.92439287641662 1993 7.05054151624549 1994 8.40746248479113 1995 8.13116726835138 1996 7.62790221949473 1997 8.039568650759959 1998 8.9784808322645 1999 7.26476203945973 2000 7.03718058201406 2001 7.2614804889173294 2002 5.97831325785597 2003 6.70681042049184 2004 5.863505934236231 2005 5.17451307801862 2006 4.91462443690633 2007 4.56028846597294 2008 5.5522257070231 2009 4.91732399394523 2010 5.42203816025789 2011 4.763315491824479 2012 5.1212418881640405 2013 4.7910519336755995 2014 4.38524512900119 2015 3.94577677069237 2016 3.83296309077707 2017 3.98063244501644 2018 4.0353959175721 2019 4.02391956596479 2020 3.66559393307463 2021 4.0128565542918295 2022 3.93701552980635