Year % of general government expenditure 1988 10.3337737612391 1989 10.4500622232423 1990 10.2820063762895 1991 10.4265603011602 1992 11.5816318191492 1993 11.1583204797183 1994 11.826078338874101 1995 11.4423578518563 1996 11.9872758971844 1997 12.2654684840685 1998 12.3268919009626 1999 14.158162194723001 2000 12.3096970956816 2001 10.5139681996053 2002 10.123572344162 2003 9.87597269802709 2004 10.1051512216247 2005 9.47922027308811 2006 9.77435613164746 2007 10.3575151103263 2008 8.130350288489641 2009 9.7293875642094 2010 11.172283054077301 2011 10.5570175438596 2012 10.0977162339507 2013 9.213862743516781 2014 9.67347446019768 2015 10.5059748939552 2016 10.567240412764999 2017 9.215898981303381 2018 8.91062400524295 2019 9.18007765330027 2020 9.35278823889101 2021 9.22822259310393 2022 7.70210538959145