Year % of general government expenditure 1988 13.2325838555105 1989 12.5129265770424 1990 14.691444600280501 1991 15.240833932422701 1992 13.350700097688001 1993 11.0300554420776 1994 9.272137227630969 1995 9.08682970608032 1996 12.366452991453 1997 13.4445534838077 1998 12.100344318740799 1999 10.1295097132285 2000 9.79525360632852 2001 9.88593155893536 2002 8.43222985633979 2003 10.843989769821 2004 6.8944353518821595 2005 8.101625220285879 2006 8.249292285916491 2007 8.11937312437479 2008 8.35368832437714 2009 8.44258214404248 2010 7.87858621709553 2011 7.54730608117868 2012 6.96624644164295 2013 6.781533605155859 2014 9.05517941773866 2015 8.47865764979639 2016 8.99423107955462 2017 7.832884427032321 2018 8.20050135961931 2019 9.49144295302014 2020 10.9474449899982 2021 10.1677516274412 2022 9.15752171925011