Year % of total safety net benefits 2008 48.6945211122189 2009 29.9776433474926 2010 25.6636206223413 2011 24.4433735754218 2012 22.9526823124519 2013 22.734060880365 2014 23.2563060190167 2015 25.1272455103608 2016 25.8329347299034 2017 26.8499691204109 2018 24.9031456916985 2019 25.1111258158295