Year % of expense 1998 38.01083596389755 1999 40.6240842401391 2009 31.14587247157078 2010 31.10656772383195 2012 40.84713441255172 2013 37.786358711275234 2014 31.362383163193403 2015 33.742539313306914 2016 36.834633009084335